4 Credit Rating Myths
Looking to buy a house? Make sure you know what will truly hurt and help your case with lenders -- and don't fall for the misinformation mortgage lenders can spread.
By Liz Pulliam Weston
There's a lot of misinformation being propagated about what does and doesnít hurt your credit score, and much of it is coming from sources who should know better: mortgage lenders.
Now, let me say first that Iíve worked with several excellent lenders who really knew their stuff and kept up to date, not only on loan trends but on the information thatís available about credit scoring. Thatís important, because the FICO credit score, in its various permutations, is used in three-quarters of all mortgage lending.
But what I heard from several lenders responding to my recent column, ď8 big mortgage mistakes and how to avoid them,Ē was the kind of bad advice that can cost you money and keep you from getting the best loans.
So if your mortgage broker gives you any of the following advice, take a tip from me: Find a new broker.
Closing accounts can help your credit score
No, no, no. For the umpteenth time: Closing accounts can never help your credit score, and may hurt it.
Every time I write this, I get more e-mail from people who say their mortgage lenders told them exactly the opposite. Itís true that having too many open accounts can hurt your score. But once youíve opened the accounts, youíve done the damage. You canít repair it by shutting the account, and you may actually make things worse.
The credit score looks at the difference between your available credit and what youíre using. Shut down accounts, and your total available credit shrinks, making your balances loom larger, which typically hurts your score.
The score also tracks the length of your credit history. Shutting older accounts can also make your credit history look younger than it actually is, which can hurt your score.
Rather than closing accounts, pay down your credit card debt. Thatís something that actually can and usually will improve your score.
Checking your FICO score can hurt your credit
Unfortunately, I heard this one from a mortgage broker who is otherwise pretty smart. He was confused about which type of inquiries hurt your score and which donít.
Applying for new credit is generally what hurts your score. Ordering a copy of your own credit report or credit score doesnít count. Those mass inquiries made by credit card lenders, who are trying to decide whether to send you an offer for a pre-approved card, also arenít going to hurt you, either -- unless you actually take them up on their offers.
If you want to minimize the damage from credit inquiries, make sure that when you shop for a mortgage you do so in a fairly short period of time. The FICO score treats multiple inquiries in a 14-day period as just one inquiry and ignores all inquiries made within 30 days prior to the day the score is computed.
For most people, one inquiry will generally knock no more than 5 points off a score (and scores typically run from 300 to 850, so thatís not a big percentage).
Credit counseling will hurt your score as much as a bankruptcy
The current FICO formula ignores any reference to credit counseling that may be in your file. Thatís been true for the last three years, after researchers at Fair, Isaac, the company that created the FICO scoring system, noticed that people getting credit counseling didnít default on their debts any more often than anyone else.
Your ability to get a loan could still be hurt by credit counseling, however. Your current lenders may report you as late, because youíre not paying what you originally owed or because your credit counselor isnít sending your payments in on time. Late payments do hurt your credit score.
Lenders consider other factors besides credit scores in making their decisions, as well. The factors they look at can vary widely. Most want to know your income, for example. Some want to know how much savings you have or whether youíre a homeowner. Some will find credit counseling disturbing, while others see it as a good sign.
The mortgage lenders who donít like credit counseling generally treat its enrollees the same as if they had filed for Chapter 13 bankruptcy. Chapter 13 is the kind of bankruptcy that requires a repayment plan and is looked at somewhat more favorably than Chapter 7, which allows you to erase many of your debts. You might still be able to qualify for a loan from one of these lenders, although your interest rates will almost certainly be higher than if you had perfect credit.
If you plan to get a mortgage soon, and youíre not already behind on your debts, itís probably smart to steer clear of credit counseling. If youíre already in trouble, however, a good credit counseling agency might be able to help you get back on track.
Your FICO isnít the only score you need to check
This came from lenders who thought the FICO score is offered by only one of the three credit bureaus: Equifax.
In reality, all three of the bureaus offer FICO credit scores using the formula developed by Fair, Isaac, but they each give the scores a different name. At Equifax, the FICO is known as the Beacon credit score. At TransUnion, itís called Empirica. At Experian, it goes by the unwieldy title of ďExperian/Fair, Isaac Risk Model.Ē
Complicating matters further is that youíll probably have three different scores from the three different bureaus, largely because the bureaus donít all share the same data. One bureau may list more accounts for you than another, for example, and the differences (in types of accounts, payment histories, credit limits and balances) will be reflected in the score that bureau computes for you.
Because of those differences, it does make sense to pull and examine your credit reports from all three bureaus before you apply for a big loan like a mortgage. Many mortgage lenders take the middle score from the three bureaus when making their decisions, so fixing errors in all three reports before you shop for a loan is smart.
When it comes to comparing your scores, however, you may be stuck. Equifax is so far the only bureau that makes it easy for consumers to get the same FICO score that lenders see. The scores typically provided to consumers by Experian and TransUnion aren't FICO scores, and they're different from the scores these bureaus provide to lenders.
But the ways you improve your credit score are the same in any case: Correct errors. Pay your bills on time. Pay down your debt. And apply for credit sparingly.